Should I choose vinyl or laminate?
It depends on the room. Vinyl planks have a plastic core and resist water on their surface, so they suit rooms where water may reach the floor, such as basements and laundry rooms. Laminate has a core of pressed wood fibres and suits dry rooms; some products are rated for kitchen spills. In dry living areas both work well, so compare products, not just types.
Homeowners choosing between vinyl and laminate for a kitchen, basement, condo or whole floor, who want a fair comparison before they visit the showroom.
What is the real difference between vinyl and laminate?
The core. A vinyl plank has a plastic core, and the plank resists water on its surface. A laminate plank has a core of wood fibres pressed into a dense board, which can swell if water gets in.
On top, the two look alike: a printed design under a clear protective layer. The core decides most of the rest: where each floor can go, how it is installed and what it needs underneath.
How is each plank built?
Both are made of layers. From the top, vinyl has a wear layer, a printed layer, a core and sometimes a pad. Laminate has a wear layer, a decorative layer, a fibreboard core and a backer.
- Wear layer. The clear top layer that protects the design. On vinyl, its thickness is given in mils (thousandths of an inch). On laminate, it is graded by an AC rating (abrasion class), from AC1 to AC6.
- Vinyl cores. SPC (solid polymer core, often called stone-plastic composite) is denser and harder. WPC (expanded polymer core, often called wood-plastic composite) is lighter and softer underfoot. Flexible vinyl bends; it is glued down or loose-laid (laid flat without clicking).
- Laminate core. Wood fibres pressed together under heat and pressure. The backer underneath is usually melamine or another water-resistant material.
The vinyl flooring guide and the laminate flooring guide go into each one in depth.
How do vinyl and laminate compare, point by point?
Here is each point side by side. Products differ within each type, so the product’s own instructions and warranty decide the details.
| Vinyl | Laminate | |
|---|---|---|
| Construction | A clear wear layer, a printed layer and a plastic core: rigid (SPC or WPC) or flexible. Some have a pad attached. | A clear wear layer, a decorative layer, a fibreboard core and a backer. |
| Look and feel | How real it looks depends on the print and texture. SPC feels firm; WPC and attached pads feel softer. | How real it looks depends on the print and texture. The rigid fibreboard plank feels firm. |
| Sound | Depends on the pad and the subfloor, in the room and in the room below. | Depends on the underlay and the subfloor, in the room and in the room below. |
| Water | The plank resists water on its surface. The edges and the subfloor need their own protection. | Water-resistant for a rated time, such as 72 hours. The core can swell if water gets in. |
| Scratches, dents and wear | The wear layer (in mils) protects the print. SPC resists dents better than WPC. | The AC rating grades wear-through only; scratches and dents are tested separately. Thicker planks resist impact better. |
| Repairs | Replaced plank by plank, not refinished. Loose-lay planks lift out. | Replaced plank by plank, not refinished. Repair kits suit light marks on some products. |
| Installation | Click (floating), glue-down or loose-lay, by product. | Click (floating), over an underlay, with a vapour barrier over concrete. |
| Care | Sweep or vacuum; clean as the care guide says. Steam only if the product allows it. | The same, and wipe spills up at once. |
| Warranty conditions | Installation per the instructions and approved cleaners; a second underlay only if approved. Flooding is excluded. | Installation per the instructions, a vapour barrier on concrete and approved cleaners. Flooding is excluded. |
| What drives the cost | The product and the boxes you buy; click or glue-down installation; preparation, removal and trim. | The product and the boxes you buy; click installation; the underlay; preparation, removal and trim. |
Each floor’s price is on its product page. What drives the price is below, and the flooring cost guide covers every line of an estimate.
Which numbers and labels should I compare?
Compare the wear layer on vinyl, the AC rating on laminate, the overall thickness and the certifications. Each one measures one thing, so read it for what it is.
| Label | What it tells you | Check as well |
|---|---|---|
| Wear layer, in mils (vinyl) | How thick the clear top layer is. One mil is 0.001 inch (0.0254 mm), so 20 mil is about 0.5 mm. | Overall thickness is a separate figure. Charts that match mils to rooms are typical retail guidance, not a standard. |
| AC rating, AC1 to AC6 (laminate) | A European class (EN 13329) for how well the top layer resists wearing through. | Scratches, dents, water and fading are tested separately, so ask about each one. |
| Overall thickness | How thick the plank is, sometimes with an attached pad counted in. | It is separate from the wear layer and the AC class. Thicker laminate resists impact better. |
| Certifications | FloorScore or GREENGUARD: emissions tested against set limits. NALFA (laminate): lab tests in 14 performance categories, plus proof of meeting formaldehyde emission limits. | A limit is not zero emissions, and FloorScore covers the product, not its installation. Ask whether your floor is certified. |
Which suits my rooms and my household?
Both can fit most rooms. What changes is the check you make first. Here is when each one fits, in eight common situations.
Kitchens
Vinyl fits when- You want a plank that resists spills on its surface.
- Its water rating suits a kitchen, and spills are wiped up soon.
- The water rating, and what the warranty asks.
Basements
Vinyl fits when- The product is approved below grade (below ground level).
- Its manufacturer approves it below grade, over a vapour barrier.
- A moisture test on the concrete, against the product’s limit.
Bathrooms
Vinyl fits when- The product is approved for bathrooms.
- That product is approved for bathrooms, and standing water is wiped up at once.
- That the instructions name the room, even for vinyl sold as waterproof, and how the edges are sealed.
Condos
Either fits when- Your building approves the floor and the underlay.
- The rules in writing, including any sound rating.
- For a plank with a pad attached, whether another underlay is allowed.
Pets
Vinyl fits when- Water bowls and wet paws are part of daily life.
- Spills are wiped up soon, and the water rating suits the room.
- Scratch testing, trimmed nails, and mats under bowls (on vinyl, mats without a rubber or latex backing).
Children
Vinyl fits when- You want a softer floor to play on: a WPC core or an attached pad.
- You prefer a firm floor, with a rug in play areas.
- Felt pads under chairs, and spills wiped up quickly.
Rentals
Vinyl fits when- You want planks that are simple to swap: loose-lay planks lift out.
- The rooms are dry.
- A spare box from the same production lot, and the cleaners the warranty allows.
Budget-conscious renovations
Either fits when- Both come in a wide range of prices, and in our catalogue the two ranges overlap.
- Products with the same features, and the whole job: preparation, underlay, removal and trim.
Which handles water better?
Vinyl. The plank and its plastic core resist water on the surface. Laminate is water-resistant: its fibreboard core can swell if water gets in, so how long a spill can sit depends on the product’s rating.
- Vinyl sold as waterproof. The plank resists water on its surface. Water can still run through the joints at the edges to the subfloor.
- Water-resistant laminate. Many products are rated in hours, such as 72. That is how long water can sit on the surface before it gets into the joints, under the warranty’s conditions.
- Wet rooms. The instructions we reviewed ask for sealed edges: silicone where the floor meets walls, cabinets and fixtures. Even vinyl sold as waterproof can be limited to certain rooms, so check that the instructions name yours.
- Warranties. For both types, the ones we reviewed exclude flooding, leaking or burst pipes, and moisture rising from below.
Which stands up better to scratches, dents and wear?
The product matters more than the type. Compare the vinyl’s wear layer with the laminate’s AC rating, then ask how each was tested for scratches and dents.
- Wear. A thicker vinyl wear layer, or a higher laminate AC class, gives more protection before the design wears through.
- Scratches. Grit on shoes scratches floors. Mats at the doors and felt pads under chairs protect both.
- Dents. SPC vinyl resists dents better than WPC, and thicker laminate resists impact better. Put wide, flat protectors under heavy furniture.
- Sun. Some vinyl instructions ask for protection from strong, direct sun, to reduce fading and heat expansion. Blinds help both floors.
Lifespan has no standard figure in years for either type. A floor lasts longest when its wear layer or AC rating suits the traffic. Keep water off it, and care for it as its guide says.
Which feels and sounds better underfoot?
Feel is personal, so stand on both. Sound comes in two kinds: walking noise in the room, and impact noise in the room below. Both depend on the underlay and the subfloor as much as on the plank.
How each one feels
SPC vinyl and laminate are rigid and feel firm. WPC vinyl is softer underfoot, and an attached pad adds cushioning; a cork pad adds warmth too. Stand on both in the showroom, in socks.
The two kinds of noise
- Walking noise in the room. Footsteps heard in the same room. A lab test (EN 16205) measures it on concrete.
- Impact noise in the room below. Footsteps heard downstairs, or by a neighbour below. A lab test (ASTM E2179) measures it on concrete as a “delta IIC” (ΔIIC) figure: how much the covering raises the Impact Insulation Class.
- Your own floor. A figure measured on concrete applies to concrete; a wood-joist floor behaves differently.
Ask for the product’s tested sound figures, with the underlay you will use, and check them against your building’s rules.
How are they installed, and what does the subfloor need?
Click planks, in vinyl and in laminate, lock together and float: they rest on the subfloor (the base below) without nails or glue. Vinyl also comes as glue-down and loose-lay planks. Either way, the subfloor must be clean, dry, flat and firm.
- Flatness. Each product sets a tolerance; 3/16 inch over 10 feet is common, and some ask for tighter. An underlay follows dips, so low spots are filled or levelled first.
- Concrete. It is tested for moisture first (ASTM F2170 or F1869), against the product’s limit. Laminate goes over a vapour barrier: a plastic sheet that slows moisture from the slab. One set of instructions we reviewed says an attached pad does not count as one. Some rigid vinyl asks for a vapour barrier too.
- Underlay. Laminate goes over an underlay, separate or attached. Where vinyl has a pad attached, a second underlay goes in only if its manufacturer approves. An unapproved one can strain the joints and void the warranty.
- Gaps and settling in. Floating floors need a small gap at the walls, hidden by the trim, often about 3/8 inch (10 mm) for laminate. Some products also sit in the room for about 48 hours first. The instructions decide both.
- In-floor heating. Only where the manufacturer approves it, below its maximum floor-surface temperature (26 to 29.4 °C in the instructions we found). Some products are not approved for it.
- Old floors. Homes built before 1990 may have asbestos in building materials, old floor tiles among them. Have a floor you suspect tested by a professional before it is disturbed.
Installation is completed by The Flooring Mart’s own in-house installation teams. We do not use subcontractors, which is why we can stand behind our flooring installation work with a 2-year limited workmanship warranty. Read about our installation and subfloor preparation.
How do I care for and repair each one?
Care is much the same: keep grit off, wipe spills up promptly, and clean as the product’s care guide says. Repairs are the same too: a worn or chipped plank is replaced.
- Cleaning. Sweep or vacuum, then use the cleaner the care guide names. Warranties ask for approved cleaners.
- Steam. Product by product, in both types. Many care guides advise against steam; some products are approved for steam mops. Check yours first.
- Furniture and mats. Felt pads under chairs; wide, flat protectors under heavy furniture. On vinyl, use mats without a rubber or latex backing, which can discolour it.
- Repairs. Both have a printed layer under a clear coat, so there is no wood to sand. A plank is cut out and replaced; loose-lay planks lift out. Some laminates have repair kits for light marks.
- Spare boxes. Keep one or two from the same production lot. One warranty we reviewed asks owners to keep five planks for testing.
The warranties we reviewed, for both types, ask for:
- installation as the instructions say;
- a moisture test, and a vapour barrier on concrete where required;
- approved cleaners;
- proof of purchase.
Some also ask you to keep a few spare planks.
Which costs less, and what drives the price?
It depends on the products you compare. Both come in a wide range of prices, and in our catalogue the two ranges overlap. The installed cost also depends on the work around the floor.
- The product. The price per sq ft, on each product page, for the full boxes you buy. On 2 November 2026 our vinyl ran from $1.99 to $4.85 per sq ft and our laminate from $1.99 to $3.29, for material.
- The installation method. In our price list, click vinyl and click laminate share one starting installation rate, $2.25 per sq ft of the coverage you buy. A click project in either under 400 sq ft has one all-inclusive installation price. Glue-down vinyl has its own rate, adhesive included, and a minimum installation charge.
- The rest of the job. Underlay or vapour barrier where needed, subfloor preparation, removal of the old floor, trim, transitions, stair nosing and delivery, then HST.
The flooring cost guide explains every line with worked examples, and the installation calculator prices your own rooms.
How can I decide quickly?
Start with the room and water, then the feel and the look. If most of your answers fall in one list, start there; if you are between the two, compare two products side by side.
Start with vinyl when…
- Water may reach the floor: a basement, laundry room or mudroom.
- Water bowls, wet boots and spills are part of daily life.
- You want a softer step: a WPC core or an attached pad.
- You want a plank that can be glued down or loose-laid.
Start with laminate when…
- The room is dry: a living room, bedroom, hallway or office.
- You prefer the firm feel of a rigid fibreboard plank, after standing on both.
- You find the look you want, with an AC rating and a water rating that suit the room.
Talk to us first when…
- Your condo has flooring rules or a sound rating to meet.
- The basement has had water before.
- The floor will go over in-floor heating.
- One floor will run through a large open area.
- The old floor is several layers deep, or is old vinyl or sheet flooring in a home built before 1990.
- You want to see two products side by side.
For a suggestion based on all your rooms, try the Flooring Match Guide.
What should I check before I buy?
Check these on the product page, the instructions and the warranty, or ask us in the showroom.
Before you choose vinyl or laminate
- Each room, and where water could reach the floor
- Rooms below grade or over concrete, and a moisture test planned
- The product is approved for every room it goes in
- Vinyl: the wear layer, the core and any attached pad
- Laminate: the AC rating, the water rating and any attached underlay
- The underlay and vapour barrier the instructions ask for
- Condo rules in writing, and tested sound figures
- In-floor heating approval, the care guide and the warranty’s conditions
- Your budget, including installation, preparation and trim
Print this page with your browser’s Print command; it prints as a clean checklist.
What should I do next?
- Compare floors in the vinyl and laminate collections.
- Price your rooms in the installation calculator, and book a free in-home measurement there.
- Visit the showroom at 55 Healey Rd, Unit 2, Bolton, ON L7E 5A2 (Mon–Fri 9:30 AM–8 PM; Sat 10 AM–7 PM; Sun 11 AM–6 PM) to stand on both, or call 905-872-7557.
Sources we checked
The technical statements on this page follow these sources. Where products differ, the product’s own instructions and warranty decide.
- ASTM International, ASTM F1700 (vinyl tile and plank) and ASTM F3261 (rigid-core flooring); ASTM F410 (wear-layer thickness), F2170 and F1869 (moisture in concrete) and E2179 (impact sound); scope listings checked 2 November 2026.
- European standards EN 13329:2023 (laminate floor coverings and their AC classes) and EN 16205 (walking noise), listings checked 2 November 2026; ANSI, summary of the NALFA white paper on wear resistance and AC ratings (4 January 2023).
- Resilient Floor Covering Institute, Rigid Core and FloorScore; UL, GREENGUARD Certification; checked 2 November 2026.
- North American Laminate Flooring Association, What is laminate?, Laminate Flooring FAQs and Product Certification, checked 2 November 2026.
- NIST, Guide to the SI, Appendix B.9 (one mil is 0.001 inch), checked 2 November 2026.
- Health Canada, Chemical safety for do-it-yourself projects and renovations (asbestos in homes built before 1990), checked 2 November 2026.
- Manufacturers’ installation instructions, warranties and care guides for vinyl and laminate (water, flatness, moisture, underlay, expansion space, in-floor heating, steam; several brands), reviewed 2 November 2026.
- The Flooring Mart price list and catalogue (installation methods; vinyl and laminate price ranges), read on 2 November 2026.
